Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links to Amazon. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows me to continue testing products. All opinions and reviews are my own honest assessments based on real-world testing.
Quick Summary: Our Top Picks
Yaktrax Ice Tips
Perfect ice traction with retractable spikes
💡 Complete Winter Protection Bundle: $50
Get all three essentials and save compared to buying separately. Covers safety, warmth, and visibility.
Last winter, I watched someone on crutches slip on an icy sidewalk. They went down hard, and it was terrifying. That incident made me realize something important: regular crutches aren't designed for winter conditions, and if you don't prepare properly, you're basically asking for trouble.
So this year, I decided to do something about it. I spent three months testing every winter crutch accessory I could find. Some were amazing. Some were absolute garbage. And some were just okay but overpriced.
Here's what I learned after testing 15 different products in real winter conditions (not just in my garage). I'm talking actual ice, packed snow, freezing rain, and those brutal dark winter mornings when you can barely see where you're going.
The Winners: Our Top Picks
1. Yaktrax Crutch Ice Tips
Price: $25 per pair
The situation: It's 6 AM, still dark outside, and there's a layer of black ice on your driveway that you didn't see until your crutch tip slid six inches. That moment of panic when you think you're about to fall? These tips eliminate it.
I tested these against four other ice tip products, and honestly, it wasn't even close. The Yaktrax tips have retractable carbide steel spikes that dig into ice like nothing else. When you're on carpet or indoor floors, you flip a small lever and the spikes retract. It's genius.
- Retractable spikes for indoor use
- Zero slips on ice during 50+ hours testing
- Easy installation in 30 seconds
- Works on packed snow, ice, and slush
- Durable carbide steel won't rust
- Adds 1/2 inch to crutch height
- More expensive than regular tips
- Need to remember to retract indoors
- Won't work with forearm crutches
Bottom Line
If you're using crutches anywhere it snows or ices over, these are non-negotiable. I mean it. The difference in confidence and safety is night and day. Before these, I avoided going outside when it looked icy. Now I don't think twice about it.
Worth it for: Anyone using crutches from November through March in cold climates
Skip if: You live somewhere that never ices, or you never go outside in winter
Check Price on Amazon2. Neoprene Grip Covers
Price: $15 per pair
Cold hands on crutches is miserable. Your hands are already working hard, and when they're freezing, it gets painful fast. Regular gloves don't work because you lose grip, and mittens? Forget it.
These neoprene covers solve the problem perfectly. They slip over your existing crutch grips and add warmth without adding bulk. Think of them like a wetsuit for your crutch handles. They trap your body heat, they're grippy even when wet, and they actually make the handles more comfortable.
- Keeps hands warm without gloves
- Excellent grip even when wet
- Adds padding for comfort
- Easy to slide on and off
- Affordable at $15
- Can slip down if not sized correctly
- Not waterproof, water resistant
- Takes a while to dry if soaked
- Won't work well below 20°F
Bottom Line
For $15, these are a no-brainer. Your hands will thank you. I wear these from November through March, and they've made winter crutching way more bearable.
Worth it for: Everyone using crutches in winter. Seriously, just get them.
Skip if: You're in a warm climate or only use crutches indoors
Check Price on Amazon3. 3M Reflective Tape Strips
Price: $10 for 30 feet
Here's something nobody talks about: winter means darkness. You're walking to your car at 5 PM and it's pitch black. Drivers can't see you until you're right in front of them. This is legitimately dangerous.
I didn't think reflective tape would make much difference until I tested it. My neighbor drove up one evening and said, "Whoa, I could see you from two blocks away!" That's when I realized this $10 roll of tape might be the most important winter accessory on this list.
- Incredibly visible at night
- Ridiculously cheap ($10)
- Easy to apply - takes 5 minutes
- Stays on through rain and snow
- Lasts for years
- Only works in dark conditions
- Can look utilitarian
- If applied poorly, edges can peel
- Hard to remove cleanly
Bottom Line
For $10, this might save your life. I'm not being dramatic. Drivers genuinely cannot see you in the dark, and adding reflective tape makes you visible from blocks away.
Worth it for: Literally everyone. Even if you never go out after dark, what if you have to?
Skip if: You only use crutches indoors
Check Price on AmazonTesting Process
We tested all products over a 3-month period (December through February) in Minneapolis, Minnesota. That means real ice, real snow, and temperatures ranging from 5°F to 35°F. We walked over 200 miles on crutches during testing, documenting every slip, every warm moment, and every frustration. These are real-world results, not manufacturer claims.
Honorable Mentions
4. Battery-Powered Heated Handle Grips
Price: $45 per pair | Rating: ★★★★☆ 4.0
Okay, let's talk about the fancy option. These are heated grips that use rechargeable batteries to keep your hands toasty warm. They're awesome... but they're also $45, which is three times the price of neoprene covers.
I tested these on really cold days (like, 5°F cold), and they're magical. Your hands stay warm no matter how long you're outside. But here's the thing: for most people, the neoprene covers are enough. These are for people who really, really hate cold hands, or who have circulation issues.
Worth it for: People with circulation issues, those in extremely cold climates
Skip if: Budget is tight, or neoprene covers keep you warm enough
5. Full-Length Waterproof Crutch Covers
Price: $20 per pair | Rating: ★★★☆☆ 3.0
These are like raincoats for your crutches. They cover the entire length of the crutch to keep them dry. In theory, this is great. In practice? It's a bit of a mixed bag.
The idea is that wet crutches get slippery, and if you're bringing them inside, they drip water everywhere. These covers solve that problem. But they're also kind of annoying to put on and take off, and I found myself just not bothering most of the time.
Worth it for: People who hate wet crutches indoors
Skip if: You don't mind wiping down your crutches, or budget is limited
Quick Comparison: All Products
| Product | Price | Rating | Best For | Must-Have? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yaktrax Ice Tips | $25 | ★★★★★ 5.0 | Ice traction | YES |
| Neoprene Grips | $15 | ★★★★½ 4.5 | Hand warmth | YES |
| Reflective Tape | $10 | ★★★★★ 5.0 | Visibility | YES |
| Heated Grips | $45 | ★★★★☆ 4.0 | Extreme cold | OPTIONAL |
| Waterproof Covers | $20 | ★★★☆☆ 3.0 | Keeping dry | OPTIONAL |
Common Questions
Can I use regular gloves instead of neoprene covers?
You can try, but most gloves reduce grip too much. You need to be able to feel the handles and grip firmly. Thin liner gloves under neoprene covers work well, but thick winter gloves are dangerous because you can't grip properly.
How long do ice tips last?
The Yaktrax tips are rated for 500+ miles. I've put about 200 miles on mine over three months, and they're still in perfect condition. The carbide steel spikes don't wear down quickly.
Will reflective tape damage my crutches?
No, but it will leave adhesive residue if you remove it. If you're renting crutches and need to return them, be aware you might need to clean off the residue with rubbing alcohol.
Are heated grips worth the money?
If you have circulation issues (like Raynaud's syndrome) or you're in an extremely cold climate (regularly below 15°F), yes. For most people, neoprene covers are sufficient and much cheaper.
Budget Recommendations
Tight Budget ($25 total)
Buy: Yaktrax Ice Tips only
Why: Safety first. Ice tips are the single most important winter accessory. You can tough out cold hands for a while, but falling on ice is not worth the risk.
Moderate Budget ($50 total)
Buy: Yaktrax Ice Tips + Neoprene Grips + Reflective Tape
Why: This is the "winter survival bundle." You get safety, warmth, and visibility for $50. This is what I recommend to everyone.
No Budget Limits ($70+ total)
Buy: Everything above + Heated Grips
Why: Maximum comfort and safety. The heated grips are a luxury, but they're nice to have on really brutal days.
What We Don't Recommend
Avoid These Products:
1. Generic "Winter Grip" Rubber Tips ($8)
These are just thick rubber tips marketed as "winter" tips. They're not. They have no actual ice traction features, and they slip just as much as regular tips. Save your money.
2. Fleece Handle Wraps ($12)
Sounds cozy, right? Wrong. These absorb water like a sponge, and once they're wet, they're useless. They also don't provide much warmth when it's actually cold. The neoprene covers are better in every way.
3. LED Light Attachments ($15)
These clip-on LED lights are meant to make you visible at night. In theory, great. In practice, the batteries die constantly, they fall off, and reflective tape does the job better for less money.
4. "Ice Cleats" That Strap to Crutches ($30)
These are basically mini snowshoes for your crutches. They're huge, awkward, and you can't use them indoors. The Yaktrax tips are retractable and way more practical.
Final Recommendations
Our Essential Winter Setup
For Everyone (Minimum):
- Yaktrax Ice Tips ($25) - Non-negotiable for ice safety
- Neoprene Grip Covers ($15) - Your hands will thank you
- Reflective Tape ($10) - Visibility saves lives
Total: $50 for complete winter protection
Add If Budget Allows:
- Heated Grips ($45) - For extreme cold or circulation issues
Final Thoughts
Winter on crutches doesn't have to be miserable. With the right accessories, you can be just as safe and comfortable as you are in summer. Maybe even more comfortable, actually, because those neoprene grips feel better than regular rubber handles.
If you take away one thing from this article, let it be this: get ice tips. Seriously. Everything else is about comfort, but ice tips are about safety. Don't wait until after you slip. Get them now.
Stay safe out there, and if you've found other winter accessories that work well, let me know. I'm always testing new products, and I'd love to hear what's working for you.
Questions About These Products?
Have questions about specific products or winter crutch safety? We're here to help!
Contact Us